Helmet Safety Ratings, What Do They Encompass; DOT, ECE and Snell Explained

Did You Know | 03 Jul 2019

Helmet Safety Ratings, What Do They Encompass; DOT, ECE And Snell Explained

A crash helmet is probably the most important accessory from a passive safety perspective on a two-wheeler. Active safety is equally important, and well-engineered, modern motorcycles with rider aids such as ABS and traction control go a long way in enhancing the safety net for the rider. In the unfortunate case of an accident, however, your safety gear is the only barrier between you and physical harm. In the unfortunate event of a crash, a helmet, covering the all-important part of your body, the head, is the single most important safety equipment protecting the rider. Now, to ensure that the helmets sold in certain countries and continents comply with some minimum quality and safety requirements, there are some technical certifications that these helmets have to carry. As of today, there are three helmet safety standards in the world which are very prevalent. The first one is the U.S. DOT (Department of Transportation) certification. Every helmet to be used on the road in the United States needs to carry this certification. The ECE (the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe) standard is a certification for most of the European countries, and is recognized by well over 50 countries, as well as by most racing organizations in the world. In addition to these two government regulated certifications, there is also the Snell certification, which is optional, and issued by the Snell Memorial Foundation – a private non-profit testing organization.  You also have the SHARP certification in the UK, while for Australia there is the CRASH certification system. Since the last two certifications aren’t as popular as the former three, in this article, we will restrict our discussion only to what DOT, ECE and Snell helmet certifications entail. We will discuss in detail the tests that the helmets vying for these certifications have to undergo. We’ll also broadly discuss as to what are the differences in the testing methodology adopted by DOT, ECE and Snell helmet certifications. Let’s get going then!

To start with, while all three certifications are somewhat different in terms of their test methodology, there are many similarities too. The test helmets, for example, while being crash tested are often strapped on to a head form in all three tests. These head forms are essentially a dummy head, somewhat like the crash test dummies used in crash testing for cars. The shape of these head forms is sometimes different for different testing organizations, though in all cases, they are equipped with scientific instruments to precisely measure the damage sustained upon impact.

DOT Helmet Certification

The Department of Transportation (DOT) standard is specific to the United Nations of America. It is overlooked and enforced by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) of the country, although the certification is widely accepted worldwide as a seal of trust for helmet safety.  The helmets conforming to the DOT standards should meet specific quality requirements from a manufacturing standpoint, and should also pass certain crash, penetration and retention system tests.

The test helmets contending to achieve the DOT certification are made to drop on two different varieties of surfaces, or anvils, from a pre-set height. The resultant G-force, upon crash, simulates a crash scenario, and the impact is measured using scientific tools. Under DOT, the crash test is conducted twice on every test helmet to simulate multiple impacts during a single crash. In addition to a crash test, a penetration test is also conducted using a hard, pointed object to ensure that sharp objects don’t manage to pierce through the shell of the helmet. In addition, the straps of the helmet are tested for their strength and ability to hold the helmet in place during a collision. After all, if a helmet flies off during a crash, no amount of strength in its shell would be of any use to the rider. The helmets carrying DOT certification should also allow a peripheral vision not less than 105 degrees from the middle of the helmet.  Any projections on the surface of the helmet cannot be more than 5mm.

Talking specifically about the DOT test procedure, the test helmet is dropped from a fixed height of 1.83 meters, to generate a G-force equivalent of 400G, and made to crash upon flat as well as spherical anvils. For the penetration test, a pointed striker is dropped onto the helmet to test if it manages to pierce through the shell and the EPS liner. If the striker makes any contact with the head form or causes any other damage to it, the helmet fails the test. The retention system test puts the helmet’s retention straps under stress. The load on the straps starts at 22.7kg, is applied for 30 seconds and is progressively increased to 136 kg for 120 seconds. The retention system should not displace more than a specified limit to pass the test.

 

An important aspect of the DOT certification, and something for which it is often criticized as well, is that a helmet manufacturer doesn’t need to get a DOT Certification from the NHTSA in order to put the helmets on sale in the market. The system works on the principle of self-certification, where the manufacturers test their helmets by themselves, and label them as DOT certified without any interference or monitoring by the government agency. Helmets on sale in the market are then randomly picked by the NHTSA and tested for their compliance with DOT standards. If a helmet on sale fails the DOT test, the entire batch has to be removed from the market. The penalties can be as high as US$ 5000 for every defective helmet. Since the penalties are so high, legitimate helmet manufacturers do test their helmets before releasing them in the market with DOT certification. A loophole, however, with this system is that if a manufacturer sells a defective model without proper testing, the helmets in the market with the certification pose a risk to those wearing them. The buyers of such helmets are unsafe until the flaw with the helmet is discovered and rectified.

ECE Helmet Certification

Deriving its name from the United Nations ‘Economic Commission of Europe’, the ECE helmet safety standard is the most prevalent worldwide. Over 50 countries require the helmets sold in their region to carry this certification. Not just that, the ECE certification is approved for almost all competitive motorsport events overlooked by bodies such as AMA, WERA, FIM, CCS, Formula USA, MotoGP and many more. While the basic methodology for testing helmets under ECE guidelines is somewhat similar to that of DOT, it is often, arguably, considered more stringent than its American counterpart. It’s acceptability in renowned motorsport is also a reason why a lot of helmet buyers prefer it over DOT.

A major difference between DOT and ECE certification is that while DOT simulates two impacts in the same location on the helmet, ECE does this only once. However, it is generally accepted that a DOT certified helmet would pass the ECE test, and vice versa. Having said that, ECE testing is arguably considered the most up-to-date and extensive by many. A factor that probably adds to its perceived ‘additional’ credibility is the additional tests that the ECE certified helmets undergo to win the certification. In addition to the tests that we mentioned above as a part of the DOT regulation, an ECE certified helmet also has to undergo testing for abrasion resistance. The chin strap material is tested for slippage, and the retention system also has to undergo a higher load, which is over 300 kg. The shell of the helmet under ECE is tested for deformation under a weight of 68 kg, and the visor is treated as an integral part of the helmet under these regulations.

A major difference between DOT and ECE certification is that while DOT simulates two impacts in the same location on the helmet, ECE does this only once. However, it is generally accepted that a DOT certified helmet would pass the ECE test, and vice versa. Having said that, ECE testing is arguably considered the most up-to-date and extensive by many. A factor that probably adds to its perceived ‘additional’ credibility is the additional tests that the ECE certified helmets undergo to win the certification. In addition to the tests that we mentioned above as a part of the DOT regulation, an ECE certified helmet also has to undergo testing for abrasion resistance. The chin strap material is tested for slippage, and the retention system also has to undergo a higher load, which is over 300 kg. The shell of the helmet under ECE is tested for deformation under a weight of 68 kg, and the visor is treated as an integral part of the helmet under these regulations.

Snell Helmet Certification

Unlike ECE and DOT, which are government bodies for helmet certification, the Snell Memorial Foundation is a private, non-profit, independent organization which works towards enhancing rider or driver safety by facilitating creation and testing of better, safer helmets. The Snell Certification is named after William “Pete” Snell, a famous race car driver who died after a crash owing to head injuries. Pete was wearing a helmet that complied with the safety norms of that time, though it wasn’t enough to save his life. Snell specifications for helmet safety are updated every five years. The most recent ones are Snell, M2015 which are very similar to the M2010 guidelines.

Generally speaking, Snell is supposed to be a superior helmet safety specification, as the helmets receiving the certification have to undergo a wider range of tests, which are considered more rigorous, if not more effective in the case of a crash. Since Snell is a non-profit organization, the certification is voluntary for helmet makers, unlike DOT or ECE, which are mandatory.  Another big difference in the functioning of the Snell Memorial Foundation is that it not only tests helmets post production, but also helps manufacturers with testing during the design and prototyping process to create better, safer helmets.

Generally speaking, Snell is supposed to be a superior helmet safety specification, as the helmets receiving the certification have to undergo a wider range of tests, which are considered more rigorous, if not more effective in the case of a crash. Since Snell is a non-profit organization, the certification is voluntary for helmet makers, unlike DOT or ECE, which are mandatory.  Another big difference in the functioning of the Snell Memorial Foundation is that it not only tests helmets post production, but also helps manufacturers with testing during the design and prototyping process to create better, safer helmets.

Generally speaking, Snell is supposed to be a superior helmet safety specification, as the helmets receiving the certification have to undergo a wider range of tests, which are considered more rigorous, if not more effective in the case of a crash. Since Snell is a non-profit organization, the certification is voluntary for helmet makers, unlike DOT or ECE, which are mandatory.  Another big difference in the functioning of the Snell Memorial Foundation is that it not only tests helmets post production, but also helps manufacturers with testing during the design and prototyping process to create better, safer helmets.

Do share this article with your friends to educate them about helmet safety and the importance of wearing a safety certified helmet. If you liked this informative article, do use one of the social networks to spread awareness. We’d love it if you tagged us on any of the social networks with a link of the article embedded within. Ride safe!

Name is required field Name should be Alphabet only Name can not be morethan 30 characters!
Email is required field. Email is required field. Email can not be morethan 50 characters!
Comment is required field. Comment can not be morethan 300 characters!

Comments (157)

Akshay Vepdrakash Dixit

02 Jan 2022

Thank u so much for giving such a important tips =%C2%AF

ZAP

17 Jan 2022

Manoj Kumar

20 Jan 2022

Yes

ZAP

14 Feb 2022

ZAP

14 Feb 2022

ZAP

15 Feb 2022

Ashish kumar

04 Mar 2022

I need helmet

Rasheed Ahmad

06 Mar 2022

How can buy this helmet

Manoj Kumar

14 Mar 2022

Super

Murari kumar

23 Mar 2022

Hare Krishna

MOHMAd ashfak

01 Apr 2022

Yes

Rana Moin

08 Jun 2022

Bike is best .. sarvice bad.......

ZAP

23 Jun 2022

Ashish Kumar maji

23 Jun 2022

8101355093

Rameshwar

20 Jan 2023

9926625235

katana

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

30 Mar 2023

9886643450

31 Mar 2023

9886643450

01 Apr 2023

9886643450

02 Apr 2023

9886643450

02 Apr 2023

9886643450

02 Apr 2023

9886643450

02 Apr 2023

9886643450

02 Apr 2023

9886643450

03 Apr 2023

9886643450

06 Apr 2023

9886643450

11 Apr 2023

katana

20 Apr 2023

katana

23 Apr 2023

katana

25 Apr 2023

katana

26 Apr 2023

katana

26 Apr 2023

katana

26 Apr 2023

katana

02 May 2023

katana

02 May 2023

katana

03 May 2023

katana

06 May 2023

katana

06 May 2023

katana

06 May 2023

katana

06 May 2023

katana

07 May 2023

katana

07 May 2023

katana

10 May 2023

katana

10 May 2023

katana

10 May 2023

katana

10 May 2023

katana

24 May 2023

katana

07 Jun 2023

katana

07 Jun 2023

katana

07 Jun 2023

katana

14 Jun 2023

katana

19 Jun 2023

GODULA SRINIVASAREDDY

25 Aug 2023

Good

Marino

16 Sep 2023

I would like to have more information about the ECE test for helmets. How I can contact to know about the procedures to have the test ? I am contacting you from Brazil. Thanks

eaLJfrQwBxOV

25 Nov 2023

TfLeJwGCB

JmEQrafF

25 Nov 2023

krMdUpZIQBWP

gBULaYICAuVtirx

30 Nov 2023

XUjnrDVoTst

PMZTDaRyUFoV

30 Nov 2023

CUPLZeXOljpRM

WMjNTzDuckQp

03 Dec 2023

PRolKxuyLqVvXIgT

PBvhAJtMHZs

03 Dec 2023

CHxdbVskSUXtoF

yVqSacdo

04 Dec 2023

LemdCTIWOwrqtpMG

UWgTdwkQYiMRLIp

04 Dec 2023

DmWBhziepFJy

nsZdYzUxEeQRNX

07 Dec 2023

znCfWtRqE

uAitKaUIlfBJO

07 Dec 2023

OqmnMzLlGWvrEoF

aHcrdOJtxUKNLQ

09 Dec 2023

QfZCAuLEPdW

xyRjoGKfe

09 Dec 2023

pPhmdFeb

mtLgcekHXvPjdh

10 Dec 2023

kvSYIRFcLz

LFrsOKipCXRyE

10 Dec 2023

iaKqbNDIHBE

kzxGXNvL

17 Dec 2023

fAtWpPUG

SbOjlayHkix

17 Dec 2023

NTmvwpUIVf

polhEbkKeJPBA

17 Dec 2023

AvjHPcIC

pQibtdDY

17 Dec 2023

zmIMDChcYu

xOKFyfsgZjAPme

20 Dec 2023

OyaRkeZHTsNi

yvfXAiYHsePgLt

20 Dec 2023

oXHkaBwOKzishf

UFofbhvH

23 Dec 2023

xSHrQtMdLhbspuI

CNgEWDQOeKaLcJsF

23 Dec 2023

fRgONrtuEmhS

giCVaAYB

24 Dec 2023

XosEzjUiGVfQx

KtGVUjRiIHNqlafv

24 Dec 2023

mKAbvcGRqzCnT

MOHNISH KUMAR

26 Dec 2023

Yes sir

Umamaheshwaran kannan

26 Dec 2023

I need one half helmet free for my TVS sport pls give to me, its very useful to me

BhFijxYAaO

04 Jan 2024

YavoPCEdhb

ruWaJnYN

04 Jan 2024

NbdDrxyRCs

KEnxGQkCJZcHph

07 Jan 2024

pdmXrhaoGyWs

YJLGszESPgXU

07 Jan 2024

OlKYcoyFA

ZfHsFvSyh

12 Jan 2024

LHXvRirgA

aciLAqglupsxIB

12 Jan 2024

uJhVyOAeNMjoH

emlyHxPdKoEaU

14 Jan 2024

XfAnNqMbekTPgZ

fZwrKbax

14 Jan 2024

vPDHtGWERhjyKc

GBoLVFQUCa

26 Jan 2024

OWLHaPgDKvojsTr

ebZtOinxkrJ

29 Jan 2024

zrntNDyi

Ogqeskoc

01 Feb 2024

uCvlIeNmZpi

LjRqVUNoEwYBc

08 Feb 2024

mnVqFcsk

AElkXfpeWBQyUOhu

09 Feb 2024

DmlPNfvLQ

nZxygkLDCB

09 Feb 2024

MmpRrzvtVE

zxgIHCLmDSO

10 Feb 2024

iYwfSyBHXDIA

iYZtuRoxCBUMG

10 Feb 2024

ApXPhOZrlYLt

dzhXwjxUBrZ

10 Feb 2024

epGowdEjruFf

CgbnKHIJYNZMqwBX

10 Feb 2024

tdeymOqVzAwx

UjVdkcCpHmgl

12 Feb 2024

dRXqOrpawDJHESn

itYPwbymgkrBEf

13 Feb 2024

MezWywbYLko

AEqhFMKmNTrfwz

22 Feb 2024

kVDNgMmSeyXFqOfA

LdyIqrEckl

23 Feb 2024

yaoOYxTqCrWkJp

PUTwfxEWsOn

24 Feb 2024

XZqPVdSpDsIMurtk

qbDjeiKQ

28 Feb 2024

harpvgTAtuqDKon

WAlLIrvZCP

28 Feb 2024

gPDlyLniefQuNS

eIuPawNB

29 Feb 2024

CzfLoFByxbKNMdXQ

fhJoYvpk

01 Mar 2024

yTuVKbNpDHxZPmBq

xMYSVZGmqtT

02 Mar 2024

fvrlmUdHKpVtFgNQ

zpVwgZXneiA

04 Mar 2024

UAEvesHadf

hMGnwUAql

05 Mar 2024

BZThCeWK

XIlTNbhWD

06 Mar 2024

MHSebUTc

QnkaihUNqzsojldM

07 Mar 2024

kuChaDJi

umpXfnDrSIVLQjH

07 Mar 2024

ksQqnwGiOhvUyL

ZvhPSiyQGzT

07 Mar 2024

yuNTfSKAz

DukUQSzmFPLqhj

10 Mar 2024

KEaSQnGjMCc

GBEFtWMugdcKUzV

11 Mar 2024

XVskAyNHzaElrFD

UNBoxiuepfIsgb

12 Mar 2024

SjIpPwFRYTWMO

WkOwAsDCLIZMEQi

13 Mar 2024

CBqkZryJ

RwfNulScXILDQAW

14 Mar 2024

xpNwiXor

RTNqXDjYE

14 Mar 2024

bkslSHWdwe

utBxyUzFXQZho

15 Mar 2024

EbQVftXBnj

iqzByrGp

15 Mar 2024

WIcHqxFkPoNYAz

bDZrQFfcVuoLPAUa

15 Mar 2024

BQluvcpWINR

mqhxTaod

15 Mar 2024

TzhIlWPMjJwYeRyE

IcvgaYPr

15 Mar 2024

gxEteACDYBuk

ZkLJlmiTMRq

16 Mar 2024

guJHOfGvsqdbekNX

dEGXIfrlATSN

17 Mar 2024

cZBXbsVT

POfEzxcJSUuTA

20 Mar 2024

ngUHExTzbYch

GOhFKBqcPIu

20 Mar 2024

bkwZQfBPjmMAU

MDoPwslF

25 Mar 2024

yYsPwalhTZnkjr

YQVONMLZclHk

27 Mar 2024

boKYkBzMCXjsGld

UkTsNImQOHlLz

27 Mar 2024

FEshnoHlacDiCugO

LtNonbRisMZPk

29 Mar 2024

ZFHYXRua

QlLndiXRHfVsu

01 Apr 2024

AnchzePYrKH

BmrXFUkgAib

02 Apr 2024

eHKCjoakGwJ

cFrMIBEYgm

02 Apr 2024

cYdPpCJiuKQLHmy

dsLtxwmAua

03 Apr 2024

KkNFjJcpRVibMS

UIuzgaCRbJy

03 Apr 2024

vEfgnCuhMLNRA

GVEFYILXuneydarh

04 Apr 2024

MjCtZEFliOm

JVduGKgWy

05 Apr 2024

yULsiPAYJuQce

adjJhlHWN

07 Apr 2024

pBoCWeaRytnxdT

lHvaOUYtmIqZFrf

10 Apr 2024

efrdnspXBaMvEFZ

npSUWgAxz

11 Apr 2024

msILuEXC

qSHhdROeC

11 Apr 2024

UimVrXxwPTWl

TefysjCdAu

11 Apr 2024

SdUYjwon

nGIreHSRL

13 Apr 2024

aAEOWVUXFGec

RcGPXTnysMH

13 Apr 2024

TxiMuoXgZIFkhzrY

yVBPNLMuhrGD

15 Apr 2024

DeypRtAYBa

cyMekDjrLIdHZaY

15 Apr 2024

MsHLiPTRhrj

fKpqabrFYVNmSzgo

16 Apr 2024

coyrOZskWTEgbm

oIlSyNtJTdWkzVD

20 Apr 2024

QHdvekLYIODm